Dr. Squatch lets subscribers customize their Squatch Box, change scents before a refill, and get early access to new products. On September 2, 2025, Unilever acquired 98.7% of Dr. Squatch for €1.243 billion, according to Unilever’s SEC filing. For Shopify brands selling replenishable products, the subscription experience offers a practical model: give subscribers control over what arrives, reasons to look forward to the next box, and easy ways to adjust instead of canceling.
Replicating that approach takes more than a recurring billing setup. Modern subscription management platforms can help brands build flexible subscription strategies through bundle builders, customizable customer portals, and segmented promotional tools that give subscribers reasons to stay beyond basic convenience. This guide covers build-a-box subscriptions, limited-edition drops, self-service portals, upsells, and loyalty mechanics, along with the metrics brands should track for each.
Key Takeaways
- Dr. Squatch subscribers can change products and scents before their next refill and get early access to new products.
- Build-a-box controls let subscribers choose what arrives. Delivery-frequency controls let them choose when it arrives.
- Across more than 10,000 launches analyzed by EQL, an average of 48% of entrants were new to the brand.
- Pause, skip, and swap options give subscribers alternatives to cancellation.
- Stay AI reports that mobile devices account for 80-90% of customer portal traffic.
- Stay AI offers add-ons and longer-supply upgrades to grow order value, Smart Dunning for failed payments, and a separate recovery process for out-of-stock orders.
Understanding the Dr. Squatch Subscription Model: More Than Just Soap
Dr. Squatch offers one-time purchases and recurring Squatch Boxes. Subscribers can change the products or scents in an upcoming refill as their preferences change.
For a brand considering a similar model, the financial question is how much each bundle contributes toward recovering customer acquisition costs. Compare the revenue left after discounts, product costs, and fulfillment for a single-item order and a bundled order. Then track how many customers place a second and third order.
Brands that treat subscriptions as a growth channel rather than passive recurring billing can test bundle offers using subscriber acquisition tools that present bundles prominently at signup.
Building Subscriber Loyalty with Custom Gift Boxes and Build-Your-Own Subscriptions
A build-a-box model gives subscribers control over what arrives. Delivery timing matters separately. In Kibo’s U.S. survey, 55% of respondents without a product subscription said they wanted to control how often they bought the product.
Brands that want to address both concerns can pair a box builder, which lets customers choose which products appear in recurring orders, with easy frequency controls. Subscribers get flexibility while brands maintain predictable recurring revenue.
Build-a-box subscriptions can also deliver:
- Higher engagement through interactive product selection
- Better product data as brands see which items subscribers choose most often
- Alternatives to skipping or canceling when subscribers want to change the products in their next box
- Gift-giving opportunities when customers build boxes for others
Implementing a Build-A-Box Experience for Your Brand
Stay AI’s subscription management platform supports bundle and starter-kit subscriptions that enable build-a-box models. Merchants can configure subscription purchase experiences through Buy Box extensions without heavy reliance on engineering.
Key implementation considerations include:
- Product catalog organization that makes selection intuitive
- Bundle pricing logic that incentivizes larger boxes without overwhelming choice
- Swap functionality allowing subscribers to change products between orders
- Portal-based customization so subscribers can adjust boxes after initial purchase
The customer experience tools within modern subscription platforms let brands create these flexible experiences while maintaining operational control over fulfillment and inventory.
Leveraging Limited-Edition Drops to Drive Engagement and Urgency
Limited-edition product drops create urgency without requiring discounts. Across more than 10,000 launches analyzed by EQL, an average of 48% of entrants were new to the brand.
The psychology behind drops draws on several purchase motivators:
- Fear of Missing Out (FOMO) creates urgency to act
- Perceived Value increases when scarcity signals exclusivity
- Sense of Belonging emerges as subscribers access products before the general public
In a PYMNTS and Scalefast survey of 2,298 U.S. consumers, published in 2021, 43% said they had participated in a product drop, flash sale, or private sale in the previous month.
Creating Hype with Exclusive Subscription Offers
Stay AI’s ExperienceEngine enables targeted promotional campaigns with gifts, discounts, upsells, and cross-sells, segmented by churn risk or subscriber value. Brands can combine segmentation with portal banners to promote subscriber-first drop windows.
Effective drop strategies for subscription brands include:
- 48-hour subscriber-first windows before general availability
- Portal banner promotion announcing drops directly to logged-in subscribers
- Segmented access where high-LTV subscribers get earliest access
- Quick Actions that let subscribers add drop items with one click
The key is creating genuine scarcity without artificial manipulation. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission’s dark patterns report identifies countdowns that reset and low-stock messages shown despite ample inventory as examples of misleading urgency. State the actual deadline or availability when promoting a drop.
Streamlining Subscriber Experience with Stay AI’s Intuitive Customer Portal
The customer portal is where retention is won or lost. Stay AI reports that mobile devices account for 80-90% of customer portal traffic. Test common tasks such as skipping a delivery or changing a scent on a phone.
Stay AI’s customer portal provides a customizable subscriber management experience where subscribers can manage:
- Orders, skips, and pauses
- Delivery timing and frequency
- Payment information and addresses
- Full-catalog product swaps
Merchants can configure branding, layouts, dynamic banners, and other portal components without heavy engineering involvement. This no-code approach gives retention teams greater independence from developers.
Empowering Subscribers with Self-Service Options
Self-service options let a subscriber pause deliveries, skip an order, or swap a product when their needs change. Track how often subscribers use each option and how many go on to complete their next order.
Stay AI’s portal capabilities include:
- Full-catalog product swaps letting subscribers change products from the broader catalog
- Personalized Add Extras carousel for merchandising add-on products targeted by subscriber segment
- Digital Punch Cards displaying progress toward merchant-defined rewards
- Dynamic banners showing different offers to different subscriber groups
Full-catalog swaps let subscribers change their core subscription, while the Add Extras carousel provides a separate merchandising surface for incremental purchases.
Optimizing Subscription Growth and Retention with AI-Powered Tools
Subscription churn divides into two categories requiring different solutions. A failed payment can lead to involuntary churn if the billing issue remains unresolved. Dunning tools can retry eligible charges and prompt subscribers to update their payment details.
Voluntary churn requires understanding why subscribers leave and intervening before they reach the cancel button. Stay AI applies proprietary machine learning across:
- Churn Risk Prediction identifying high-risk subscribers before cancellation
- Cancel Survey Optimization testing save treatments and using ML to route subscribers toward stronger-performing offers
- WinbackEngine using reinforcement learning to determine optimal re-engagement timing for churned subscribers
Using Data to Personalize Subscriber Journeys
In Recurly’s 2024 State of Subscriptions report, 74% of survey respondents named personalization as a top reason to subscribe.
Staylien, Stay AI’s built-in AI-powered subscriptions analyst, helps teams explore churn, cohorts, subscriber behavior, and product performance without manually building reports. Teams can investigate what drives churn for specific products or identify subscriber groups with elevated risk.
Stay MCP brings live Stay AI subscription data into Claude, allowing teams to build custom dashboards around their own business priorities rather than relying exclusively on predefined reporting.
Driving AOV and LTV with Strategic Upsells and Cross-Sells in Your Subscription Program
Brands can use a box insert to introduce another scent or product, then offer subscribers a way to add it to their next order through the customer portal.
Boosting subscriber AOV requires multiple touchpoints:
- Post-purchase upsells presenting subscription offers after checkout
- Portal-based add-ons through the personalized Add Extras carousel
- Quick Actions enabling cross-channel campaigns for add-ons and swaps
- Tiered discounts rewarding longer tenure with progressively larger discounts
Maximizing Subscriber Value with Smart Merchandising
Stay AI’s 30-to-90-Day Subscription Upgrade Playbook helps move subscribers from 30-day to 90-day supply cadences through:
- Post-Purchase Upsell presenting longer-supply upgrades after purchase
- Quick Actions delivered through Klaviyo email, portal banners, or Cancel Survey
- Variant-Based Frequency Sync aligning subscription frequency with selected supply variants
Stay AI reports up to 22% higher lifetime value for subscribers on longer-supply cadences. The Stay team builds these upgrade flows for brands, reducing implementation complexity.
Checkout URL campaigns create pre-filled checkout links containing products, selling plans, and discounts for use across email, SMS, landing pages, and advertising.
Seamless Management of Your Subscription Operations with Stay AI’s Tools
Scaling a subscription program adds operational complexity. Universal Segments allow merchants to define subscriber audiences once and reuse them across customer experiences, promotions, cancel flows, automations, and analytics, so a segment targeting high-LTV subscribers at risk of churning can flow through dashboards, cancellation experiences, portal banners, and automated interventions without rebuilding audience logic.
Scaling Your Subscription Box Business with Efficiency
Stay AI reports that Bulk Updater processes 8,000+ actions per hour and is at least 6× faster than competing bulk update tools. Supported use cases include product swaps, price changes, promo codes, and subscription-status updates.
Automations trigger defined subscription changes based on merchant-configured conditions, handling:
- Product swaps and frequency changes
- Quantity changes and subscription upgrades
- Moving affected subscriptions to a replacement SKU when a product is retired
Smart Dunning supports payment recovery with failure-aware retry logic. Smart Dunning can retry a failed payment up to 20 times. Merchants using the configurable Dunning Scheduler can set up to 30 retries per schedule.
Out-of-Stock Order Recovery supports up to 90 retries for inventory-related order issues, with targeted Klaviyo notifications, bulk swaps, and one-click swap buttons in emails. This keeps inventory recovery separate from payment dunning.
Building a Cohesive Customer Loyalty Program for Your Subscription Brand
Subscription loyalty extends beyond discounts. The goal is creating reasons to stay that build over time.
Stay AI’s Digital Punch Cards display subscriber progress toward merchant-defined rewards inside the customer portal, so subscribers can see how close they are to the next reward.
Tiered Discounts reward longer subscriber tenure with progressively larger discounts. This mechanic:
- Gives subscribers a visible reason to keep an active subscription
- Makes accumulated tenure part of the subscription’s value
- Rewards loyalty within the subscription program itself
Designing Rewards That Keep Subscribers Coming Back
Effective loyalty programs for subscriptions focus on:
- Progress visibility so subscribers see what they are working toward
- Achievable milestones that create regular reward moments
- Exclusive access to products, content, or experiences
- Community elements that connect subscribers to each other
Stay AI reports that OLIPOP’s subscription revenue grew 35% after migration. In a separate case study, Stay AI reports that Magic Spoon retained 40% of subscribers past their third order.
Why Stay AI Powers Subscription Success for DTC Brands
Dr. Squatch’s model shows how product choice, subscriber-first access, and flexible management can give customers reasons to keep a subscription. Stay AI operates as a complete AI-powered subscription management and growth platform for Shopify brands, spanning acquisition, subscription management, subscriber experience, AOV growth, retention, payment recovery, analytics, and winback.
Machine learning and churn-risk modeling support optimization across the subscriber lifecycle. Stay AI reports that brands switching to its platform saw average changes of 28% higher recurring revenue, 32% higher add-on revenue, 28% lower churn, and 39% fewer customer service tickets.
Key capabilities that support Dr. Squatch-style subscription strategies include:
- Bundles and Buy Boxes enabling build-a-box subscription models
- Portal banners and segmentation for limited-edition drop promotion
- Full-catalog product swaps giving subscribers control
- ExperienceEngine for churn-risk targeted promotions
- Cancel Survey with AI optimization testing save offers and routing subscribers toward stronger-performing treatments
- WinbackEngine for ML-timed re-engagement
Stay AI supports 250+ integrations and is compatible with most other Shopify apps. Stay AI reports 1,000+ completed migrations involving tens of millions of subscribers and provides white-glove migration support.
For brands ready to build subscription programs that give subscribers reasons to stay, Stay AI provides the connected infrastructure to execute bundle-first acquisition, flexible subscriber experiences, and retention optimization.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can brands implement a build-a-box option for a subscription service?
Organize the product catalog into logical groupings, then set up the bundle and its eligible products in Stay AI. Subscribers can edit an existing bundle through the portal’s bundle selector. To let subscribers add or swap to the bundle itself, enable the bundle parent product for the relevant action in the portal’s product settings. Test bundle configurations to see which drive the strongest conversion and early retention.
What are the best strategies for using limited-edition drops to boost subscriber engagement?
Offer subscriber-first access windows before general availability, and announce drops through portal banners and segmented emails. Consider giving the highest-LTV subscribers earliest access, and use Quick Actions so subscribers can add drop items with minimal friction. Use a countdown only when the advertised deadline is real, and make sure any low-stock message reflects actual availability. Track engagement by drop type.
How does Stay AI help in reducing churn and increasing subscriber retention?
For voluntary churn, Stay AI uses machine learning to identify high-risk subscribers, enabling targeted offers through ExperienceEngine, while Cancel Survey tests save treatments. For involuntary churn, Smart Dunning uses failure-aware retry logic to recover failed payments. WinbackEngine times re-engagement with churned subscribers, and Universal Segments let brands apply the same audiences across these retention tools.
Can Stay AI integrate with existing Shopify stores and marketing tools?
Yes. Stay AI supports 250+ integrations and is compatible with most other Shopify apps. Documented integrations include Klaviyo, Attentive, Postscript, Gorgias, and Zendesk. The platform can send events to Klaviyo, including out-of-stock notifications and Winback Ready signals. Quick Actions work across Klaviyo, Postscript, and Attentive, and the Shopify Accounts integration embeds subscription management into Shopify customer account pages.
What kind of analytics does Stay AI provide to track subscription business performance?
Stay AI provides dashboards covering cohort analysis, product performance, churn analysis, payment recovery, and cancel-survey analytics. Product Performance distinguishes products that perform well at acquisition from those that perform well on recurring orders. Staylien, the built-in AI-powered subscriptions analyst, helps teams explore churn and cohorts without manually building reports, while Stay MCP brings live subscription data into Claude for custom dashboards.
How does Stay AI support payment recovery for failed subscription orders?
Smart Dunning supports payment recovery based on billing failure behavior and failure type, retrying a failed payment up to 20 times. Merchants using the configurable Dunning Scheduler can set up to 30 retries per schedule. Inventory issues follow a separate process: Out-of-Stock Order Recovery supports up to 90 retries, with Klaviyo notifications listing affected items and one-click swap buttons in emails.

