Alleyoop is redefining beauty with efficient, multi-functional products, so you can spend less time getting ready and more time living life to the full. As they like to say, they’re “on a mission to reinvent the beauty game with efficient tools that empower you to get in, get out, and make moves that matter — because you matter.”
Challenges
Alleyoop’s business continues growing, but like many subscription brands, the team was itching to find a solution that allows them to test new ways of maximizing the AOV and LTV of their existing enthusiastic subscriber base. They were also seeking clarity in their subscription data – so they could understand more deeply how their subscription business was performing.
The Solution: Stay AI
Alleyoop switched to Stay Ai in 2022. They now leverage Stay’s suite of features to offer subscribers VIP discounts, exclusive promotions, and beautifully branded email notifications – all contributing to the brand’s impressive 27% growth in recurring subscription revenue in 2023. The team especially loves Stay’s Customer Portal, which features a dynamic product carousel highlighting products available for one-time add-ons. They can then track the revenue generated from these add-ons directly in Stay’s dashboard, alongside related metrics such as average subscription revenue and recurring subscription revenue.
“Stay AI is a no-brainer for any brand that wants to crush it with subscriptions. So many other apps lack in functionality and features where Stay shines. We're huge fans!”

Strategy
Here are just a few of the strategies the Alleyoop team has implemented to result in such incredible growth!
Offering Subscriber-Exclusive Discounts for One-Time Add-Ons: One of the ways Alleyoop engages its large subscriber base is by offering their subscription discount on current subscribers’ one-time add ons. With this strategy, the Alleyoop team is able to increase subscriber AOV, enhance LTV and subscriber loyalty by offering a VIP experience, and boost subscriber acquisition by offering a tangible sub program benefit.
Displaying One-Time Add-Ons in the Customer Portal: Stay Ai’s no-code solution allows Alleyoop to select which products they’d like to offer and display as one time add-ons in the customer portal. The add-on carousel populates these items front and center, making the items and their associated discounts easy to view at a quick glance. It’s the perfect way to introduce new products for customers to fall in love with and add to their beauty routine!
Upselling Customers from One-Time-Add-On to Recurring Subscription Products: Alleyoop’s beauty products are fan-favorites, and they often see those one-time add-ons turn into recurring subscription add-ons once customers try them out. Using the same carousel, after a customer has tried out the product, they can then add the product as a recurring order along with their existing subscription. The team can easily send emails to customers encouraging the upgrade from one-time purchase to ongoing subscription leveraging Klaviyo Quick Actions, as well as the in-app email builder.
Results
In 2023, Alleyoop has seen massive growth in their subscription program – boasting 39% growth in subscription cart revenue, 27% growth in recurring subscription revenue, and a 58% growth in add-on revenue.
Needless to say, add-on products – as well as Stay’s comprehensive suite of subscription features – enable brands to boost the core subscription KPI’s.